The past few weeks have not been good for cybersecurity professionals. First there was the issue with eMudhra, where weak security keys could allow hackers to fake an official website to fool users. Then there was a major security flaw in PHP that allowed hackers to break into websites and take control over them without needing a password. And then came the “mother of all heists” at Binance.

In a minute-by-minute reconstruction for the Wall Street Journal, the authors walk us through the heist the industry has christened “Black October.” The piece opens, ironically, with a warning from Binance’s own founder. “No crypto wallet is 100% safe,” Changpeng Zhao wrote on X. “No tech is 100% secure.” Within hours his own customers found out what he meant.

Around 1:20 p.m. in Abu Dhabi, Binance’s security team watched more than $1 billion leave the exchange out of nowhere. A crisis team of about 100 formed within minutes, every senior executive on the call, and all they could do was watch the tally climb. One billion, then three, then past six. “The speed, scale and sophistication of the heist has left the crypto industry reeling,” the paper reports, and “for Binance and its customers, the moment arrived like a jump scare.” “It’s a really tough moment for the crypto industry,” said Ari Redbord of the blockchain-intelligence firm TRM Labs.

By then the wider market had noticed the billions going missing. “Unconfirmed, but possibly massive binance hack,” one X user wrote. Binance worked with TRM, Chainalysis and Elliptic to trace the stolen coins, and leaned on stablecoin issuers Tether and Circle, who can freeze their tokens in place. Zach Witkoff, who built the Trump family’s World Liberty Financial, spotted it too. “This had all the hallmarks of a hack,” he said, pointing to funds moving through the Tornado Cash mixer. “This was so obviously a hack that someone who is a novice in blockchain analytics would know.”

It didn’t work fast enough. The hackers parked $60 million of stablecoins on the lending platform Aave and borrowed nearly $45 million of ether against it. “Ether and other assets like bitcoin can’t be frozen, so the transaction essentially moved the money beyond the outer limits of any centralized platform’s control,” the Journal writes. “Meaning, the hackers were home free.” By TRM’s count, about $2.4 billion got away into assets no one can recall.

Binance’s own messaging deepened the alarm. “It does look like a hack on Binance,” Zhao posted. “User funds are safe!” Half an hour later the company said it was pausing all withdrawals over “a potential security issue.” “The withdrawal pause sparked a new wave of panic on social media,” with some on X recalling FTX, “which famously paused withdrawals ahead of its precipitous collapse.” Binance has since reopened the gates and says it’s replaced about 95% of the stolen assets, the rest “less liquid in the market and take longer time to source at the required scale.” In the first nine and a half hours, $3.64 billion flowed out anyway.

The last word went to the billionaires. When a user noted the loss was just 0.69% of Binance’s assets, Zhao said it might run “a bit higher than that, but will cover.” Then Elon Musk answered a post comparing that reassurance to one Sam Bankman-Fried once gave, with a grimace emoji. Zhao, five hours later: “Elon, have a lot of respect for you, but bad time to troll. Please stop.”

North Korea-linked hackers are behind nearly 89% of crypto-hack losses this year. An industry that set out to replace the banks just watched a state unit take $6.3 billion in the time it takes to drink a coffee, and move most of it somewhere no one can follow. The hit has renewed the old question of “whether they will ever fulfill their promise as a viable alternative to the traditional financial system or even a safe place to store money.” Binance is the one answering it now.

If you want to read our other published material, please visit https://marcellus.in/blog/

Note: The above material is neither investment research, nor financial advice. Marcellus does not seek payment for or business from this publication in any shape or form. The information provided is intended for educational purposes only. Marcellus Investment Managers is regulated by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) and is also an FME (Non-Retail) with the International Financial Services Centres Authority (IFSCA) as a provider of Portfolio Management Services. Additionally, Marcellus is also registered with US Securities and Exchange Commission (“US SEC”) as an Investment Advisor.