As a group who loves to read, we at Marcellus often crib to each other about we see reading as a dying activity. Attention spans keep getting shorter and the younger generation seems to be able to hold a thought for just the 15 seconds of a short video. Once can’t expect this cohort to go have the patience to go through a few hundred pages of a book.

But there is a man who has taken the opposite bet and is running a business of selling more books. The New Yorker profile follows James Daunt, the chief executive of both Barnes & Noble, the biggest chain in the United States, and Waterstones, the biggest in Britain. He founded Daunt Books in London, absorbed the failing Foyles and Blackwell’s, and picked up the Tattered Cover in Denver and Books Inc. near San Francisco. He runs more than a thousand stores, close to twenty thousand staff, and four billion dollars a year in sales. “He controls more than twenty per cent of our entire market,” one American publisher tells the writer. “He is, I think, respected – and feared.”

For a man of such reach, Daunt behaves strangely. He flies economy, gets around New York by subway, and when he can he rides a folding Brompton bicycle. He spent more than twenty years running his own London shops, lugging boxes and placing orders, and a former neighbour, Sir Ferdinand Mount, calls him “the most decent tycoon you could ever hope to meet.”

When Heller raises the idea that reading is dying, Daunt laughs. “Such nonsense,” he says. Every year of his career, someone has announced that “Literary fiction is dead!” and now it’s “Nobody is reading nonfiction!” But print book sales in America are up nearly a quarter from a decade ago. The number of independent bookstores has climbed about seventy per cent since 2020. A Pew survey found thirty-eight per cent of American adults read between one and five books in 2023, and the apparent decline shrinks or vanishes once e-books and audiobooks are counted. The book historian Robert Darnton, a former director of Harvard’s library, keeps a collection of these laments going back to 1928, when Walter Benjamin wrote that “Everything indicates that the book is nearing its end.” As the Strand’s owner, Nancy Bass Wyden, puts it, “Every decade, there is a new scapegoat for why the reading public is diminishing.”

The interesting part, for anyone who thinks about businesses, is why Daunt’s model works where the optimisers failed. He shares an incisive diagnosis of the trade’s near-death. Amazon, launched in 1995, treated books as “pure commodities” – the first step in selling everything else. HMV, which owned Waterstones, answered the threat by centralising warehouses and optimising pipelines, and watched sales go into free fall. Daunt had spent two decades on the shop floor and drawn the opposite lesson. Books aren’t laundry detergent. A sale depends on whether the specific thing in front of you, that book in this shop, is good enough to pull you in.

So when he took over Waterstones in 2011, and Barnes & Noble in 2019, his first move was to loosen central control and let each store choose and display its own stock, as if it were an independent shop. What excites a reader in Manhattan need not suit one in Henderson, Nevada. He scrapped “coop,” the old practice of publishers paying for prime placement, and handed the decisions to booksellers. They ran with it. A gaming novel got an arcade machine loaded with Donkey Kong. A famine novel got a fiddler in the window. A debut the chain’s own booksellers voted to champion ended up shortlisted for the Booker.

The results were clear. At Waterstones, returns – unsold books shipped back to publishers – fell from twenty-five per cent of stock to four. A forty-three-million-pound loss in 2011 turned into an eighteen-million-pound profit by 2017. Barnes & Noble posted its first positive growth in 2021 after eight years of decline, and added sixty stores last year. Elliott Management, the hedge fund that owns both chains, is widely expected to take them public next year at a valuation of at least three billion dollars, a startling outcome for exactly the brick-and-mortar bookshop that Amazon was supposed to have killed. “Books aren’t a fixed market,” Daunt says. “The more bookshops there are, the more people will read.”

The article also looks at the difficult operational aspects of running the business. The decentralised model came with its own operational challenges. At Waterstones Daunt made all four hundred head-office staff reapply for their jobs and fired half of them. “There’s nothing good – ever – about sacking,” he says, before arguing that a bad bookseller is “actively counterproductive.” In 2019, a campaign to raise entry-level pay gathered 9,300 signatures, with 2,400 writers including Sally Rooney backing it. Daunt offered a bonus but refused the base-wage rise. “Pay is a zero-sum game,” he told the writer. “If I’m going to pay one person more, I have to pay another person less.” A campaign organiser, Usman Mohammed, called that “textbook corporate speech, where they draw a false binary.” Publishers, too, are uneasy about so much of the market resting with one buyer. To keep returns low, Daunt’s shops often place tiny opening orders, which the Knopf publisher Jordan Pavlin calls “challenging”: “We have to remain undeterred by those initials.”

Heller also touches upon a topic that is essential to any business that desires to endure. And that is succession planning. “An enterprise consolidated under a single gifted leader is secure only until that leader leaves; then it is just consolidated, and vulnerable”. Daunt says he has filled the senior ranks of both chains with like-minded booksellers who can carry on without him. Whether a business this linked to one man’s taste and nerve survives his exit is the one thing his turnaround can’t yet prove. He has no illusions about who his backers are. Asked once whether Elliott’s founder, Paul Singer, loved books, Daunt shot back, with something like pride, “No, he’s a lover of making money.” Of the firm’s ownership he says plainly, “Barnes & Noble shouldn’t be owned by private equity.”

Heller’s core argument is that reading is up, not down, just redistributed across audiobooks, BookTok, romantasy queues down the sidewalk, and translated fiction bought mostly by the young. The business works because it treats each book as a particular object worth a person’s hours, not as content to be surfaced and delivered. The piece ends with Daunt in his early years in his own shop. While showing a visitor around, Daunt would notice a book on a table and pick it up as if it were the only thing in the room, a precious object carried across the world. Then he’d hand it over. “Just read it,” he’d say.

Note: Amazon.com, Inc. is part of the holdings within the Marcellus Global Compounders Portfolio, a strategy offered by the IFSC branch of Marcellus Investment Managers Private Limited and regulated by the IFSCA. Accordingly, Marcellus, its employees, their immediate relatives, and clients may maintain interests or positions in this security. Any reference to this company is intended strictly for informational and educational purposes within the context of this discussion and should not be construed as investment advice.

If you want to read our other published material, please visit https://marcellus.in/blog/

Note: The above material is neither investment research, nor financial advice. Marcellus does not seek payment for or business from this publication in any shape or form. The information provided is intended for educational purposes only. Marcellus Investment Managers is regulated by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) and is also an FME (Non-Retail) with the International Financial Services Centres Authority (IFSCA) as a provider of Portfolio Management Services. Additionally, Marcellus is also registered with US Securities and Exchange Commission (“US SEC”) as an Investment Advisor.